Slic3r is free software, developed by alessandro ranellucci with the help of several contributors and a wonderful community. About 10% faster than ms, but printed a funky shaped hole and had extra unwanted lines. Discussion in general questions started by louis tiger, aug 3. Their job is to take a three dimensional computer model and slice it into layers to provide a 3d printer the instructions it needs to print the model. Ive search a little bit but have no idea proscontros on those software. On average, the cura prints took at least 12 the time to print as the slic3r prints did. For all my models, kisslicer was always more fault tolerant than slic3er any version vs any version of the same time. Slic3r is open source software, licenced under the agplv3 license. Cura will show the extruder path, but does not include a. I dont want to be left wondering if a problem i am encountering is a limitation of the printer or of the slicer, and it takes time to figure out reliable settings for each of these slicers why waste everyones collective time speculating on whether these alternative slicers. Slic3r and curaengine both have mostly the same features, but often express them differently. Jan 02, 2016 so slic3r is the slicer that prusa suggest however i get way better times in cura and basically the same quality. Kisslicer is available via download only, no physical copies are sent.
I 3d printed a standard 3dbenchy, using 6 popular 3d print slicing programs, and i compared the results to find the best one. Posted january 11, 20 cura vs kisslicer cura rotates the infill layer so it spans the bridge, and then applies the bridge speed on that whole layer. Ive found parameters to make cura slicing very consistently successful mostly thanks to the folks at lulzbot who sell great filament and provide great filament profileconfig files for cura but also after a bunch of experimentation. On todays show, we pit the two most popular slicing software against each other to see which can do a better print. How to slice your stl files in repetier host with slic3r. In my tests, cura prints faster especially if there are a lot of small perimeters, slic3r just makes too many tool moves to accomplish the same thing that cura does with a fraction of the moves. Kisslicer or keep it simple slicer is a 3d printer software tool. Cura developers have since joined the ultimaker team to work on the software fulltime. Diffrence between cura and slic3r slicer general prusa. Other slicing programs you may wish to investigate include cura, repetier host, and kisslicer. Netfabb is a very powerful commercial software package that is ideal for many aspects of 3d file manipulation. Cura produced a lot less strings filament not attached to anything but the bridges sagged quite a bit.
Cura was developed, hosted and maintained by 3d printer company ultimaker and its fervent community of users. Kisslicer developed by a user of bits from bytes printers, this slicer is faster even than slic3r. Many different slicing programs exist for 3d printing, but slic3r is a favorite with reprap users all over the world. After lots of headaches and failed prints of a particular object, calibration, etc.
Using a leapfrog cretar myself i heard a lot of similar expierences from um2 owner then i switched to simplify3d and that was a big leap with a much better surfaces and the best support structures. May 06, 2012 if you want to use this in rc2, you need to copy slic3r into the cura installation, on the same level as pythonpypy cura, and then select slic3r from the cura preferences. Kisslicer incorporates many advanced but easy to use slicing features, generating high quality gcode paths for exceptional prints. Basic slicing software in fact all slicing software will create paths for a 3d printer to follow when printing. Kisslicer is a worthy alternative to the other 3d printer slicer software tools on this list. The tanks and gear cubeshearts are quite technical as they have lots of surface variation and are easy to give away. Which slicer do you use which is your preference and why. While this 3d slicer software supports most desktop 3d printers on the market out of the box, if you happen to need gcode for a printer that is not on the list, you have to manually adapt the program.
Lulzbot has their own edition of cura, its the default software packaged with thousands of different printers. Difference between slic3r and cura print tips archive. File size, bridging, positive features, negative features, overhangs, slicing time, and overall quality. It can be fed stl, 3mf, and obj file formats which the 3d slicer software will. It was developed by the 3d printer giant ultimaker and used by. Prusaslicer is a featurerich, frequently updated tool that contains everything you need to export the perfect print files for your original prusa 3d printer. S3d learing curve its high but cura beta still its far from what can be done withs3d. So when you slice using repeteirhost, you are actually slicing using the embedded cura or slic3r.
The top ten best 3d printing slicer software, their pros and cons, prices. Still figuring out how to configure it best, but so far its great. Primarily blobs are greatly reduced, hole sizes are much more. Were a virtual company made up of tech experts from across the globe and we love 3d printing. With the hardware issues worked out mostly, ill return to that later and the firmware stable at what seems to work really well, it falls to the software. Both cura and slic3r started out in the year 2011 cura with original author david braam and slic3r with alessandro ranellucci. The slic3r versions and profiles listed here are not being updated at this time. Can the choice of a slicer determine the quality of a. Prusaslicer vs cura general discussion, announcements.
As the company has its roots in open source, the 3d slicer software came out as a freebie and it stayed that way ever since. Over the years, cura even added profiles for competitor 3d printers. Gcode slicing once a 3d model has been created there is an essential step before being able to print the object. I wrote a program that converts midi files to gcode, enabling my printer to play. Sep 28, 2018 on todays show, we pit the two most popular slicing software against each other to see which can do a better print. Feb 06, 2015 slicing software matters in 3d printing cura vs slic3r note. I will stick to slic3r, which besides being a work of geniuses made available for free, is very tunable, and allows me to work with multiple printers on multiple computers, with multiple people easily. Cura will show the extruder path, but does not include a built in editor. Keep it simple slicer or kisslicer is one of the most userfriendly 3d. Popular alternatives to slic3r for windows, mac, linux, android, android tablet and more. Ultimaker cura is the most used 3d slicer tool, due to being free and very. Skeinforge vs kisslicer vs slic3r real world examples with. Posted january 16, 20 cura vs kisslicer kslicer is better for speed and quality. Not the best solution, but it works for most cases.
So, hoffe du kannst bald wieder deinem hobby fronen gru. Ive done 1 print in kisslicer and its immediately obvious there are some significant improvements. Slic3r, on the other hand, produced several strings but was able to keep the bridges from sagging. Prusaslicer is a featurerich, frequently updated tool that contains everything you need to export. That is the point where most of the users become confident in 3d printing and look for more advanced software.
Diffrence between cura and slic3r slicer general prusa i3. I tried cura, kissslicer and slic3r and found the best results were always the ones from slic3r. While slic3r came out on top, i believe its worth noting how long the prints took. I was using the settings that came with the machine for slic3r. Cura was developed, hosted and maintained by 3d printer company. And that video test its crap xd anyhow s3d its better if you are willing to do a gazillion test cubes to control 40 settings in your head. Why do you think software companies give deep educationa discounts or free licences on software. I would say that the slicing quality of cura, prusaslicer, kisslicer or ideamaker is quite similar and which one the user picks depends. Once you purchase the pro key, it will be emailed to you within 48 hours. Slicing software matters in 3d printing cura vs slic3r note. The time to open a stl and the first slice time are measured together, because cura makes. As it happens, in my own personal journey ive been moving in the opposite direction, from cura to prusa slicer formerly scli3r pe. It is one of the big names in 3d printing software and for good reason. I want to go on with kisslicer, you advised me to remove the m92, m301 and m304.
Cura 3d is the friendly face of slicing software, so much so that many users dont even realize what its doing. What i like about slic3r is that you can use modifiers, sections of your model that will print differently than the rest, all in the same model. Mar 18, 2015 this is a comparison of the 3d model slicers cura and slic3r using the astroprint cloud slicer function. Imho it comes down to what system you learned first and were taught on. Using the same parameters in both software i dont understand because exists this big differences between the results, and i want to obtain the same quality in the pieces with simplify3d that with cura. These paths are instructions for geometry, and they tell a 3d printer what speed to print at for various points and what layer thicknesses to adopt if applicable sometimes it is best to do this manually. Posted on july 26, 20 by galex49 over the last few weeks, i have tested the limits of what i could achieve with a reprap mendel prusa using data from slic3r, and i could not get rid of the strings and blobs associated with moves head movements over empty space. For example, you can set the number of perimeters you want in slic3r, whereas in cura you specify your perimeter thickness. Differences in printing between cura and simplify3d. Our wiki contains detailed instructions for installing the dependencies see the relevant page. Both of these prints turned out far better than i expected. Slic3r converts your 3dimensional model typically stlobj and determines the 3d printer tool path based on the options selected. Repetier host is another free to use software package that is a bit beefier than slic3r or cura.
I switched from slic3r to cura and the part came out perfectly. Slic3r does complete perimeters, minimal blobbing and great fill so im more inclined to move forward with slic3r than go back to skeinforge and keep trying to get it right. This cura 3d guide for beginners shows stepbystep how to use cura software and to find the right settings for 3d printing. I added some comments to each slicer in none particular order or relevance. But note that not all options will work then, but it will allow you to compare the slic3r results to cura.
Kisslicer vs slic3r sorry pirvan, i have the completely opposite experience of you. This repository contains a small comparison of slicer software. This is a comparison of the 3d model slicers cura and slic3r using the astroprint cloud slicer function. Download and use the free version and see for yourself.
The repetierhost front end includes a gcode editor and will show the extruder path as you go thru the gcode, along with some tips on what the gcodes do. Kisslicer just exposes the most common and important settings and. So yes cura is a good choice as is simlify 3d or slic3r. Join the discussion on github and help us make it better.
Top 10 best slicer software for all levels 3dnatives. This was always silently implicitly on in slic3r slic3r pe prusaslicer. Explore 15 apps like slic3r, all suggested and ranked by the alternativeto user community. Prusaslicer is our own inhouse developed slicer software based on the opensource project slic3r. I dont think ive seen it ever take more than a minute. Sf50 has some more features such as skirt, and the calculation of flow rate by filament diameter. The software is very detail oriented, and focuses on technical aspects of 3d printing that experienced makers will be more drawn to. Use the profile wizards to quickly set up your printer and materials or download profiles. Reading the 3dprinting subreddit i kept seeing people talking about simplify3d and slic3r, with strong camps arguing that both are very good.
Slicer software acts as the middleman between the 3d model and the 3d printer. I will let it go on and post the result to compare it with cura and slic3r prints. If you want to compile from the source code for hacking or contributing to the development you can clone the project from the github repository. Actually, repeteirhost is a 3d printer controller software that also acts as a front end for either cura or slic3r. The only thing im noticing in slic3r is the odd missing layer and it having issues with stl files that skeinforge was fine with. Kisslicer or keep it simple slicer is a 3d printer software tool that is definitely for more technically adept makers.
Kisslicer, slic3r and slic3r prusa edition, and simplify3d all support relative extrusion. In the meantime, slic3r is still being worked on by parttime developers. So while slic3r had the better quality, there is something to be said about the speed with which the model was printed. Even though it is easy to use, kisslicer incorporates many advanced. Kisslicer is a powerful, easytouse, and fast crossplatform app that slices stl files into printerready gcode files. I thought i should bring out that fact because there seems to be some confusion as to repeteirhost being a slicer.
Cura runs it under pypy, which is a more optimized, faster version of python. A comparison of simplify3d and slic3r prusa edition ak eric. It can use slic3r or skeinforgefor slicing, or load a gcode file from cura. To extrude relative or not to extrude relative, that. The 3d model must be sliced into layers and the output translated to a numeric control language called gcode. This allows to integrate slic3r in your custom toolchain and batch operations as you like.
The reason for my move is something you detailed in your post unwanted added retractions. Dec 03, 2012 sf50 has some more features such as skirt, and the calculation of flow rate by filament diameter. Cura, matterslice and craftware do not support relative extrusion. I wanted to find ways of improving my prints and the printing experience purely in software. Kisslicer, debutants, utilisateurs avertis, gratuit38, windows, mac, linux, raspberry. Slic3r, cura, and kisslicer are all slicing programs. I have also left out at least one commonly used but not freeoss program in kisslicer one to evaluate in the future. Skeinforge in a previous post i mentioned the differences between firmware, sofware and hardware. The slicing settings were the default ones that were set by astroprint for the printrbot simple metal. Knowledge base working with 3d models slicing how to slice your stl files in repetier host with slic3r once you upgrade your host software to repetier host, you need to learn how to slice your stl in repetier host rather than downloading and opening up slic3r independently. Ultimaker cura is free, easytouse 3d printing software trusted by millions of users. It surprises me cura made such a fuss of it when they implemented it. Slicing software matters in 3d printing cura vs slic3r.
1147 727 687 1349 856 1169 989 261 587 1434 1293 299 426 235 499 824 474 621 605 419 837 513 330 1144 804 925 714 1509 180 260 544 322 850 140 173 1096 1119 115 580